What Falk checks
The reading a sceptical evaluator gives it. Unsupported claims and weak links. Falk reads across all three criteria, scoring independently before seeing what the other readers found.

Red-team reader
The reading a sceptical evaluator gives it. Unsupported claims and weak links.
The reading a sceptical evaluator gives it. Unsupported claims and weak links. Falk reads across all three criteria, scoring independently before seeing what the other readers found.
Practical and sceptical of academically attractive projects that lack deployment credibility. Spends little time on elegant writing and a lot on whether the work can be delivered at all.

Excellence reader
Objectives, ambition, methodology and the state of the art.
Learn more
Impact reader
Pathways to outcomes, uptake, and measurable change after the project.
Learn more
Implementation reader
Work plan, resources, governance, risk and effort allocation.
Learn more
Consortium reader
Whether the partners together can actually deliver what is promised.
Learn more
Sector specialist
Domain depth for your field, and what this particular call expects.
Learn moreAbout 15 minutes · before the panel
One proposal. One deadline. One opportunity to improve it before submission. Upload your proposal and the call, and get the score, the reasons and what to fix.
Start