From the evaluators
What hurts a proposal most
We asked EU evaluators to pick, from 15 common problems, the five that cost a proposal the most marks. How often each was picked:
- 1Impact not linked to the call's expected outcomes10 of 12
- 2Objectives that are not specific or measurable9 of 12
- 3Claims without evidence8 of 12
- 4A work plan that doesn't add up7 of 12
- 5Call scope or specific requirements missed6 of 12
See all 15
- 6KPIs and targets missing or unrealistic5 of 12
- 7Methodology described in generic terms4 of 12
- 8Novelty unclear against the state of the art4 of 12
- 9Inconsistencies between sections3 of 12
- 10Dissemination and exploitation plan generic2 of 12
- 11Partner roles unclear or gaps in the consortium1 of 12
- 12Effort that doesn't match the tasks1 of 12
- 13Risks generic, mitigation not real0 of 12
- 14Budget not justified against the work0 of 12
- 15Key information buried or hard to find0 of 12
Notes on EU evaluation
How EU proposals are actually evaluated
31 notes on criteria, thresholds and score bands as the published evaluation forms define them.
October 2026
- 28 October 2026How to Audit Proposal Logic Before SubmissionLearn how to audit proposal logic against EU award criteria, exposing unsupported claims, evidence chains and score-limiting gaps ahead of submission.
- 28 October 2026How to Map Call Requirements Before You DraftLearn how to map call requirements into a traceable proposal matrix, separating eligibility, award criteria and evidence before submission for evaluators
- 26 October 2026Proposal Readiness Audit Before SubmissionProposal readiness audit for EU funding exposes score risks in Excellence, Impact and Implementation before your Horizon Europe deadline closes for good.
- 21 October 20267 Best Ways to Evidence Impact in EU ProposalsLearn the best ways to evidence impact in Horizon Europe, Digital Europe and Erasmus+ proposals, with evaluator-focused tests for clear, scoreable claims.
- 21 October 2026Evaluation Panel Simulation Before SubmissionAn evaluation panel simulation exposes score-limiting claims, weak evidence and criterion gaps before an EU proposal reaches the real evaluators in time.
- 17 October 2026Fixed Price Bid Review Before EU SubmissionA fixed price bid review tests your Horizon Europe, Digital Europe or Erasmus+ proposal against the call criteria before submission closes for decision.
- 17 October 2026Proposal Evidence Checklist for EU FundingUse this proposal evidence checklist to test Excellence, Impact and Implementation claims against what EU evaluators can actually verify before submission.
- 17 October 2026How to Strengthen Proposal Evidence Before SubmissionLearn how to strengthen proposal evidence for EU funding: connect claims to call requirements, credible methods, ownership, metrics and proof before scoring.
- 17 October 2026How to Structure Work Packages for EU ProposalsLearn how to structure work packages for EU proposals, linking tasks, deliverables, milestones, ownership, dependencies and credible resource logic clearly.
- 17 October 2026How to Test Proposal Claims Before SubmissionLearn how to test proposal claims against EU evaluation criteria, expose unsupported assertions and repair score-limiting gaps before safely submission.
- 7 October 2026Proposal Score Interpretation Guide for EU BidsA proposal score interpretation guide for Horizon Europe, Digital Europe and Erasmus+: read thresholds, evidence gaps and adjudication before submission.
- 7 October 2026Bid Review Timing for EU Proposal DeadlinesBid review timing determines whether evaluators see corrected evidence or avoidable weaknesses your team has read past for weeks before submission.
- 7 October 2026Automated Versus Human Proposal Review ComparedAutomated versus human proposal review for EU funding: where each method finds weaknesses, where it fails, and when a real evaluator matters before bid.
- 7 October 2026Independent Proposal Review Service for EU BidsAn independent proposal review service tests Horizon Europe, Digital Europe and Erasmus+ drafts against call criteria before submission deadlines close.
- 7 October 2026Expert Q&A Proposal Feedback Before SubmissionExpert Q&A proposal feedback gives EU applicants an evaluator's answers on scored weaknesses before Horizon Europe, Digital Europe or Erasmus+ submission.
September 2026
- 28 September 2026EU Funding Proposals: Where Evaluators Take PointsEU funding proposals are scored against published criteria, not effort. Find the unsupported claims, gaps and risks that cost points before the submission.
- 28 September 2026Five Signs of Weak Impact in EU ProposalsLearn the five signs of weak impact that lower EU proposal scores, and how to test pathways, evidence, KPIs and uptake before submission under pressure.
- 23 September 2026Erasmus+ Application Assessment Criteria ExplainedUnderstand Erasmus+ application assessment criteria, score thresholds and the evidence evaluators expect before your proposal is submitted for marking.
- 23 September 2026Digital Europe Proposal Scoring Criteria ExplainedDigital Europe proposal scoring criteria: how evaluators apply thresholds, weights and score bands, and where drafts lose points before submission closes.
- 23 September 2026Horizon Europe Eligible Costs ExplainedHorizon Europe eligible costs explained: how personnel, subcontracting, equipment and indirect costs survive the grant agreement and evaluator scrutiny.
- 23 September 2026EU Proposal Red Team Review for Score RisksAn EU proposal red team review finds unsupported claims, missing evidence and score risks before submission, against the call's published marking scheme itself.
- 19 September 2026Horizon Europe Governance Structure ExplainedHorizon Europe governance structure explained: who sets priorities, implements calls, and how to make proposal governance score with evaluation panels.
- 19 September 2026What the Horizon Europe Implementation Section ScoresThe Horizon Europe implementation section tests delivery credibility. See what evaluators score, what loses marks, and what to repair before submission.
- 17 September 2026Horizon Europe Consortium Capacity EvaluationHorizon Europe consortium capacity evaluation identifies evidence gaps, delivery risks and governance weaknesses before they reduce Implementation scores.
- 16 September 2026How Erasmus+ Proposal Evaluation Loses PointsErasmus+ proposal evaluation tests the evidence behind relevance, design, delivery and value. Find the score-losing gaps before you submit your draft.
- 16 September 2026Why Scores Fall on the Horizon Europe Impact CriterionLearn how evaluators apply the horizon europe impact criterion, where drafts lose marks, and how to evidence credible pathways before submission closes.
- 16 September 2026What Loses Points in Digital Europe Proposal EvaluationDigital Europe proposal evaluation explained: see how evaluators test evidence, score award criteria and identify weaknesses before the deadline closes.
- 16 September 2026How Are Horizon Europe Proposals Scored in Practice?How are Horizon Europe proposals scored? See the official criteria, thresholds, weighting and the draft weaknesses that cost points before submission.
- 16 September 2026Horizon Europe Evaluation Threshold ExplainedUnderstand the Horizon Europe evaluation threshold, criterion scores, weighting and the weaknesses that can stop a well-funded proposal at the panel stage
- 16 September 2026EU Proposal Scoring Scale and What It CostsUnderstand the EU proposal scoring scale, score bands, thresholds and weighting, and find the claims that cost points to evaluators before you submit.
- 11 September 2026Horizon Europe Proposal Evaluation Explained
Prefer a series? Winning EU Funding: ten short articles by Brian Baptista, in full here.
About 15 minutes · before the panel
Evaluate
before you
submit
One proposal. One deadline. One opportunity to improve it before submission. Upload your proposal and the call, and get the score, the reasons and what to fix.
Start